IMPORTANT NOTE: So, my last thread has not gotten any support, but some. The thing is, I think this will have many positive effects on how suggestion on ROBLOX work. It is not an idea to be ignored or to be declined immediately. Yes, this does mean that S&I will potentially be removed. All threads will be gone, yes. I am aware, I am aware of ALL of this. To prevent suggestions of importance from being gone, I believe that there should be time to convert suggestions before the forum is then deleted. That way, all suggestions of value will be safe. The current suggestion system right now (this forum) is flawed. Instead of having to edit these changes on ALL of the forums (like editing threads), this format could just be implemented instead. If you're not going to support just because S&I will be gone, don't bother replying to this thread. That's not a helpful answer, at all. It's not a reason to beat on this suggestion. If you can supply REASONS why S&I is somehow BETTER then my idea, hell yes, do so. I'd love that. You're providing actual reasoning, unlike the previous feedback I've been getting. You'll have to let go of the past, sometimes, to have positive effects take place. This suggestion won't disappoint if you give it a chance.
I'm going to paste a clip from the old post. All of what is between the lines still apply to this repost. (It's edited a bit, so if you've read the old post, still continue to read what's below.)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Check these out:
http://t.co/G1dnjsdFnd
http://t.co/EJefKAuCFn
Pretty much, suggestions will sort of share the layout for models, scripts, audio, etc. Simple, yes?
Pros:
- You get to pick a genre, which makes finding suggestions easier.
- If you make an error in your suggestion, or need to make an edit, you won't need to completely repost it and lose all your feedback.
- Keeping track of how many people support will be easy.
- You could advertise a suggestion, therefore giving it more publicity.
- They show up in your inventory, just as models or scripts do, so you can easily have ALL of your suggestions (as well as supported ones) all in one place.
- It'd be more user-friendly, since many don't know about the forums.
Cons:
- Giving feedback would be hard, because of character limit in comments. (Maybe extend the limit for those specific items?)
- Enforcing the WNTS would be a bit difficult. (Maybe make it as a notice at the top while someone is typing a new suggestion?)
I can't really find out any other cons, so it seems pros overrule.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
So please, give this idea a chance. It's one of those ideas where you need to give it a chance. It may not look good at first, but soon enough, everyone will get used to it and the system will work well. Thanks, if you actually read that all. I just didn't want to repeat myself over and over, and wanted to make sure people read the whole thing.
j-frame |