ford08105Join Date: 2008-11-09
Post Count: 17788 |
Guys like Tony Romo deserve to be up there too, among others...
But who am I to say |
|
|
How is Tony Romo underrated?
Just asking |
|
ford08105Join Date: 2008-11-09
Post Count: 17788 |
@Dark
He gets a lot of ridicule despite being a great QB
But who am I to say |
|
|
Actually Tony Romo's overrated lol |
|
DiskerudJoin Date: 2014-02-17
Post Count: 7395 |
Romo is overrated if anything |
|
birmie123Join Date: 2014-05-08
Post Count: 5893 |
"inb4Cowboy fans say Tony Romo"
philip > romo
i love me some romo but rivers is better
also yeah i agree
dak in black |
|
birmie123Join Date: 2014-05-08
Post Count: 5893 |
"Romo is overrated if anything"
even though he's been one of the most criticized players in the league since becoming a starter, playing with trash teams in the years he was at his best, and is regarded by most people that aren't cowboys fans or analysts to be an above average backup at best, he is overrated.
okay.
im not saying he's underrated, but he is sure as f### not overrated.
dak in black |
|
DiskerudJoin Date: 2014-02-17
Post Count: 7395 |
Typical cowgirls fan |
|
birmie123Join Date: 2014-05-08
Post Count: 5893 |
what a statement
dak in black |
|
|
"You have to remember, Luck was in his prime last season. Ryan's aging. Ryan has gotten older, and I believe that he was and still is a great QB. He just doesn't have the ability."
So an aging Ryan puts up better numbers than a prime Luck and Luck is still considered better?
LOL....
Ryan's only half way into his career.
|
|
|
teddy is underrated you noobs |
|
|
"So an aging Ryan puts up better numbers than a prime Luck and Luck is still considered better?
LOL....
Ryan's only half way into his career."
but Luck's best year was better than Ryan's best year
|
|
|
"but Luck's best year was better than Ryan's best year"
Ryan: 32 TD's 14 INT 68.6% 2 fumbles
Luck: 40 TD's 18 INT 61.7% 8 fumbles
yeah, I'll take Ryan's best year. |
|
|
"Even though he's been one of the most criticized players in the league since becoming a starter, playing with trash teams in the years he was at his best, and is regarded by most people that aren't cowboys fans or analysts to be an above average backup at best, he is overrated.
okay.
im not saying he's underrated, but he is sure as f### not overrated"
You must be talking about a different Tony Romo. Because the quarterback i know is praised by the media. Also he's played for a solid team, it's his inconsistencies that derailed those seasons, yet he still is considered to be amongst the best quarterbacks for some reason. He's a good quarterback but he's inconsistent, which is rarely taken into account. |
|
birmie123Join Date: 2014-05-08
Post Count: 5893 |
romo's only been called a top quarterback these past few seasons
before that Romo was only mentioned for jokes about how he chokes |
|
|
"Ryan: 32 TD's 14 INT 68.6% 2 fumbles
Luck: 40 TD's 18 INT 61.7% 8 fumbles
yeah, I'll take Ryan's best year."
Ryan's line was ranked 15th in 2012 and Luck's was ranked 25th in 2013, can't really blame him for fumbling when he's getting hit a lot because of a poor line
and i already addressed that completion% isn't always telling of how good a QB is
chad pennington has the 2nd highest completion% of all time but that wouldn't influence someone to take him over Brady or Rodgers at all
|
|
birmie123Join Date: 2014-05-08
Post Count: 5893 |
also Romo has had trash offensive lines and defenses up until recently, and his defense is still pretty garbage |
|
|
Exactly, he's currently overrated, he's not a top quarterback, and he's injury prone. I'm not saying he's grossly overrated, but he is overrated. |
|
|
"he's not a top quarterback"
he's top 10 easily
|
|
|
"and i already addressed that completion% isn't always telling of how good a QB is
chad pennington has the 2nd highest completion% of all time but that wouldn't influence someone to take him over Brady or Rodgers at all"
completion percentage is one of the most important stats in defining how good a qb is lol
Aaron Rodgers will probably retire with a higher completion percentage than Pennington anyways.
Chad Pennington only played a whole season a few times. I wonder why no one thinks he's that great.
|
|
birmie123Join Date: 2014-05-08
Post Count: 5893 |
when Romo is healthy he is a top QB
unfortunately for him things only came together when he reached the twilight of his career and hid body becomes worthless |
|
|
matt schaub has played for 11 and has a higher completion% than Tom Brady
???
Brady is 13th in completion% all time but he is a better all time QB than everyone above him
Ryan had an amazing offense in 2012, Luck's team was nowhere NEAR as good as Ryan's in 2013
I would assume having 3 great targets and a reliable RB will increase your completion percentage by a lot
|
|
|
Luck's team in 2013 was nowhere near as good as Ryan's team in 2012 is what I meant, shoulda worded that better
|
|
|
Matt Ryan still threw 28 touchdowns and 14 interceptions while throwing 66% on a 6-10 team.
so cut the bs |
|
RomoismJoin Date: 2010-08-13
Post Count: 43090 |
I put Philip Rivers and Tony Romo in their own tier ## ### that could have won a SB if their ownership was competent for the majority of their career. |
|