|
I thought it would be a lovely little idea to have a box or area for legitimate people to post reviews or critiques on games.
Now you could try to do this in the comments, but hardly anyone would see it because in 8 seconds about 42 "builderman told me how to get 999999999 robux and tix etc etc" will swallow your review, and that's very frustrating.
So I thought there should be a box or section for legitimate reviews and critiques.
So instead of seeing spam, you'd see something like "Very good game, I enjoyed my time playing it thoroughly, I highly suggest you play, and then before posting your review/critique, you put X/10, say 10/10 for example, so it would look like this, but in a fancy box.
Quality game, I enjoyed my time playing it thoroughly, I highly suggest you give this game a try.
10/10
|Fair?|Unfair?|
Oh, and also other users would be able to decide whether or not the review was fair.
Good idea? |
|
|
P.S. The reviews would be reviewed themselves, so no silly spam finds its way into the critique section. |
|
|
CycrumJoin Date: 2011-10-21
Post Count: 281 |
This sounds like a good idea, and a good way to push out the spammers.
You have my support. |
|
|
|
|
UlrondJoin Date: 2011-06-23
Post Count: 11962 |
Unfortunately, you have not mentioned anything about how it will stop spam.
I've seen a game review idea before, and it really is a good idea. A stars system on it could work too. The problem is that comments cannot be moderated because there are too many of them and I fear it would be the same with reviews. |
|
|
I never said it would stop spam, but I guess an age minimum could reduce it, or you could take a survey to be a game reviewer on ROBLOX. |
|
|
ZawieJoin Date: 2010-07-04
Post Count: 6338 |
People would just spam in Review system...
|
|
|
Well ROBLOX would find some way to fix it, like I said, a survey or application for it. |
|
|
Bump, just trying to get people's opinions on this. |
|
|
I support.
@AZant
"The reviews will be reviewed"
Read the post before posting. |
|
ZawieJoin Date: 2010-07-04
Post Count: 6338 |
@Chin
There aren't enough mods to review all the reviews. If they could, they'd review the comments!
The creator can't review them because they'd decline all the bad ones... |
|
|
Bump fo jeesus
#yoloswagbanterbuspurplemonkeydishwaser |
|
|
It's a good idea, but maybe to reduce spam the creator of the game could review the ratings and let the legit ones be shown on the game's page. |
|
|
Cute's got the right idea, I would never have thought of that, they end up in your inbox maybe, saying "You have a review!" or something, and it's like the old friend requests, it has two buttons, Accept and Decline, but instead, it says Approve or Disapprove.
Thanks for the idea, cute.
#yoloswagbanterbuspurplemonkeydishwaser |
|
|
Maybe, you can only post one review per game? It completely bankrupts all spam on the Amazon store reviews, so you could maybe try that with ROBLOX too. |
|
|
Yeah, that too, and if you need to, you can edit it, just in case.
#yoloswagbanterbuspurplemonkeydishwaser |
|
|
ROBLOX might replace the comments with reviews, who knows... But, what about hats, will there be review systems for them, too? |
|
|
I don't know about replacing the commentary, cmments and reviews are two very different things, and no, they probably won't make hats reviewable, because ROBLOX makes and uploads the hats, so they don't really care, while game devs would love to hear from their players, with ways they can improve, and new features that'd make the game better, and just compliments from the people who enjoyed the game. |
|
|
@Flubbah you're welcome and I think we shouldn't replace the comments section with reviews because even though some comment sections on games are full of spam, they also give some good advice and motivational stuff and compliments like you said. |
|
ZawieJoin Date: 2010-07-04
Post Count: 6338 |
The creator cannot choose the reviews becasue the creator will only choose the Positive ones and flag the negative ones. |
|
|