|
That's exactly what I said but in a shorter way and those statements do make sense, if you want real plot holes from real movie buffs, go to IMDb and look at The Hunger Games' goofs. The movie is almost EXACTLY likethe book. |
|
|
Then explain them to me
Explain how each one isn't a plot hole
"Hit the lever!" |
|
|
The Hunger Games gets a 4.5 out of 10 from me. I wouldn't recommend it. |
|
ducky980Join Date: 2012-09-01
Post Count: 9083 |
that just means the book has plot holes too |
|
|
ummmmm I just read all of this and I just wanted to say
Plotholes are when something is just totally left unexplained and/or makes absolutely no sense. Therefore, everything Lego said is a plothole.
As the internet likes to say:
"A plot hole or plothole is an obvious mistake or missing element in the plot of a fictional work, such as a book, play, film, or TV show. These include such things as illogical or impossible events, and statements or events that contradict earlier events in the storyline.
Plot holes in film have been defined as '...contradictions in a screenplay... [which] can both be mentioned on paper or implied by the premise and universe of the screenplay.'" |
|
|
To stop rebellions, the higher ups decided to create a scenario in which everyone is on edge and ready to kill: That is what they got for rebelling, the way they stop rebellions is by separating the districts and for them to have no communication with each other.
Peeta is somehow able to perfectly disguise himself like a tree solely because he decorates god damn cakes: Okay? What's wrong with that? Maybe that's his hobby? My brother knows how to decorate cakes and he loves to paint his face into like things from movies or shows.
In a post-apocalyptic world where resources such as bread are scarce, cake decorating is a thing: Who said bread was scarce? It isn't, it's just expensive, and why couldn't they have bakery? They need to make some money and some people can afford that kind of stuff.
The trainer guy who nobody gives a sh.it about goes on and on that katniss needs to get people to like her, but nothing ever comes of it. He's the only one that actually sends her ####: But she does have to do that, and the people did donate but the money went to the "trainer guy" so he got to chose the necessities.
Katness decided that in a fight to the death, it'd be a good idea to team up with some random girl with absolutely no skills of her own: Because she reminded her of her younger sister? Katniss wanted Rue to win, she was selfless and wanted to make sure that Rue would win but Rue died.
A district of all black people who've never actually won decide that this particular year they should rebel, solely because the stupid black girl died: They have won before, who said they haven't? And they rebelled because Katniss made Rue's death into a funereal, The Capitol doesn't want their people to feel sad for the dead tributes and Katniss did it in a rebellious way since The Capitol didn't want her to do that.
The bad guys are bad guys solely for the fact that they're smart enough to train potential picks and win every year: They aren't bad guys, Katniss is just jealous and thinks that they will win the Game, Katniss knows they were innocent children but hey, it's kill or be killed! Also the "bad guys" only know how to fight because in their district, they could train them too, The Capitol and District 1 & 2 had a closer relationship.
The higher ups ##### out at the last second when Peeta and Katniss decide to threaten suicide, even though they had a multitude of ways to make sure on out lasts the other: That's why the higher-up died? Also what would you do if you were the super bowel and no one won? People would get furious that nobody won.
Peeta agreed to eat the berries: Because he was depressed and loved Katniss, when people are depressed they think about killing them.selfs
All of this was explained in the movie and book...
|
|
ducky980Join Date: 2012-09-01
Post Count: 9083 |
To stop rebellions, the higher ups decided to create a scenario in which everyone is on edge and ready to kill: That is what they got for rebelling, the way they stop rebellions is by separating the districts and for them to have no communication with each other. (Doesn't explain why the hell the Hunger Games were made in the first place, and how it will actually stop the districts from rebelling. You literally listed a reason they didn't rebel, but completely left out how that relates to the games.)
Peeta is somehow able to perfectly disguise himself like a tree solely because he decorates god damn cakes: Okay? What's wrong with that? Maybe that's his hobby? My brother knows how to decorate cakes and he loves to paint his face into like things from movies or shows. (Has had no practice other than decorating cakes and still doesn't justify cake decorating being a thing. It shouldn't be BS'd that somehow it was his hobby to paint himself into his surroundings, he got this skill out of nowhere. It's bull and it's fairly obvious.)
In a post-apocalyptic world where resources such as bread are scarce, cake decorating is a thing: Who said bread was scarce? It isn't, it's just expensive, and why couldn't they have bakery? They need to make some money and some people can afford that kind of stuff. (If it's expensive they wouldn't be able to afford it in District 12. Also with the fact that no one from that district could afford a cake in the first place.)
The trainer guy who nobody gives a sh.it about goes on and on that katniss needs to get people to like her, but nothing ever comes of it. He's the only one that actually sends her ####: But she does have to do that, and the people did donate but the money went to the "trainer guy" so he got to chose the necessities. (I agreed this wasn't a plot hole.)
Katniss decided that in a fight to the death, it'd be a good idea to team up with some random girl with absolutely no skills of her own: Because she reminded her of her younger sister? Katniss wanted Rue to win, she was selfless and wanted to make sure that Rue would win but Rue died.(Again, not a plot hole.)
A district of all black people who've never actually won decide that this particular year they should rebel, solely because the stupid black girl died: They have won before, who said they haven't? And they rebelled because Katniss made Rue's death into a funereal, The Capitol doesn't want their people to feel sad for the dead tributes and Katniss did it in a rebellious way since The Capitol didn't want her to do that. (They've had several people die before, but now that Katniss is magically the first person to show compassion towards another candidate (which is also bs), it made the whole difference.)
The bad guys are bad guys solely for the fact that they're smart enough to train potential picks and win every year: They aren't bad guys, Katniss is just jealous and thinks that they will win the Game, Katniss knows they were innocent children but hey, it's kill or be killed! Also the "bad guys" only know how to fight because in their district, they could train them too, The Capitol and District 1 & 2 had a closer relationship. (No, these guys were pretty much demonized the entire time. They viewed them like horrible people who should die, especially Cato. It wasn't until the second one where the other contestants weren't viewed as evil.)
The higher ups ##### out at the last second when Peeta and Katniss decide to threaten suicide, even though they had a multitude of ways to make sure on out lasts the other: That's why the higher-up died? Also what would you do if you were the super bowel and no one won? People would get furious that nobody won. (But the people didn't like the games to begin with. Why would they be upset from the result of a game they think is evil and cruel in the first place?)
Peeta agreed to eat the berries: Because he was depressed and loved Katniss, when people are depressed they think about killing them.selfs (Agreed, not a plot hole.) |
|
|
To stop rebellions, the higher ups decided to create a scenario in which everyone is on edge and ready to kill: That is what they got for rebelling, the way they stop rebellions is by separating the districts and for them to have no communication with each other. (Doesn't explain why the hell the Hunger Games were made in the first place, and how it will actually stop the districts from rebelling. You literally listed a reason they didn't rebel, but completely left out how that relates to the games.): Well I did explain why, when they did rebel and lost they decided to make The Hunger Games
Peeta is somehow able to perfectly disguise himself like a tree solely because he decorates god damn cakes: Okay? What's wrong with that? Maybe that's his hobby? My brother knows how to decorate cakes and he loves to paint his face into like things from movies or shows. (Has had no practice other than decorating cakes and still doesn't justify cake decorating being a thing. It shouldn't be BS'd that somehow it was his hobby to paint himself into his surroundings, he got this skill out of nowhere. It's bull and it's fairly obvious.) But it could have been his hobby? Katniss didn't really talk to Peeta until they are selected. You can't just say that a stranger can read out of nowhere...
In a post-apocalyptic world where resources such as bread are scarce, cake decorating is a thing: Who said bread was scarce? It isn't, it's just expensive, and why couldn't they have bakery? They need to make some money and some people can afford that kind of stuff. (If it's expensive they wouldn't be able to afford it in District 12. Also with the fact that no one from that district could afford a cake in the first place.) People from The Seam can't afford it but the people who don't live the poorest part of D12 could have afford it, you can't say that a person from the trailer parks can't afford a car because they can, they just need to save up for it.
The trainer guy who nobody gives a sh.it about goes on and on that katniss needs to get people to like her, but nothing ever comes of it. He's the only one that actually sends her ####: But she does have to do that, and the people did donate but the money went to the "trainer guy" so he got to chose the necessities. (I agreed this wasn't a plot hole.)
Katniss decided that in a fight to the death, it'd be a good idea to team up with some random girl with absolutely no skills of her own: Because she reminded her of her younger sister? Katniss wanted Rue to win, she was selfless and wanted to make sure that Rue would win but Rue died.(Again, not a plot hole.)
A district of all black people who've never actually won decide that this particular year they should rebel, solely because the stupid black girl died: They have won before, who said they haven't? And they rebelled because Katniss made Rue's death into a funereal, The Capitol doesn't want their people to feel sad for the dead tributes and Katniss did it in a rebellious way since The Capitol didn't want her to do that. (They've had several people die before, but now that Katniss is magically the first person to show compassion towards another candidate (which is also bs), it made the whole difference.) Well when you have a funereal it's for someone who you loved and it's suppose to be really sad and who knows maybe Rue was very well-known in D11.
The bad guys are bad guys solely for the fact that they're smart enough to train potential picks and win every year: They aren't bad guys, Katniss is just jealous and thinks that they will win the Game, Katniss knows they were innocent children but hey, it's kill or be killed! Also the "bad guys" only know how to fight because in their district, they could train them too, The Capitol and District 1 & 2 had a closer relationship. (No, these guys were pretty much demonized the entire time. They viewed them like horrible people who should die, especially Cato. It wasn't until the second one where the other contestants weren't viewed as evil.) But Katniss hated them because they wanted to kill her but later in the games, she realizes that they are innocent, the capitol made them do this, it wasn't their fault. Trust me, if innocent people were forced to kill me, I would hate them.
The higher ups ##### out at the last second when Peeta and Katniss decide to threaten suicide, even though they had a multitude of ways to make sure on out lasts the other: That's why the higher-up died? Also what would you do if you were the super bowel and no one won? People would get furious that nobody won. (But the people didn't like the games to begin with. Why would they be upset from the result of a game they think is evil and cruel in the first place?) The people did like the games, well the people in The Capitol.
Peeta agreed to eat the berries: Because he was depressed and loved Katniss, when people are depressed they think about killing them.selfs (Agreed, not a plot hole.) |
|
|
Personally, I like the concept of the Hunger Games better than the Hunger Games books/movies.
Well that's the end of this post. Remember to rate the post, comment the post, and subscribe if you want to see posts similar to this one. See ya. |
|
|
@ARROW You're having the time of your god damn life, aren't you?
Well that's the end of this post. Remember to rate the post, comment the post, and subscribe if you want to see posts similar to this one. See ya. |
|
ducky980Join Date: 2012-09-01
Post Count: 9083 |
I don't even know how to respond you, didn't really give reasons why they weren't plot holes. You just disagreed by using "but what if" for every single response. Seriously? If there is no communication from other districts how was Peeta decorating cakes for them? And who the hell do you know that lives in poverty and saves up money for a cake? wtf! |
|
|
Okay. I never even knew there were so much plot holes. Well how about opinons of the Eye of Minds by James Dashner? |
|
|
To stop rebellions, the higher ups decided to create a scenario in which everyone is on edge and ready to kill: That is what they got for rebelling, the way they stop rebellions is by separating the districts and for them to have no communication with each other. (Doesn't explain why the hell the Hunger Games were made in the first place, and how it will actually stop the districts from rebelling. You literally listed a reason they didn't rebel, but completely left out how that relates to the games.): Well I did explain why, when they did rebel and lost they decided to make The Hunger Games
You explained nothing. Instead, you danced around the point entirely. How does creating a scenario in which everyone is on edge and prepared to fight to the death stop rebellions?
Peeta is somehow able to perfectly disguise himself like a tree solely because he decorates god damn cakes: Okay? What's wrong with that? Maybe that's his hobby? My brother knows how to decorate cakes and he loves to paint his face into like things from movies or shows. (Has had no practice other than decorating cakes and still doesn't justify cake decorating being a thing. It shouldn't be BS'd that somehow it was his hobby to paint himself into his surroundings, he got this skill out of nowhere. It's bull and it's fairly obvious.) But it could have been his hobby? Katniss didn't really talk to Peeta until they are selected. You can't just say that a stranger can read out of nowhere...
That is a plot hole by definition. It isn't explained, it's just there
In a post-apocalyptic world where resources such as bread are scarce, cake decorating is a thing: Who said bread was scarce? It isn't, it's just expensive, and why couldn't they have bakery? They need to make some money and some people can afford that kind of stuff. (If it's expensive they wouldn't be able to afford it in District 12. Also with the fact that no one from that district could afford a cake in the first place.) People from The Seam can't afford it but the people who don't live the poorest part of D12 could have afford it, you can't say that a person from the trailer parks can't afford a car because they can, they just need to save up for it.
This is a scenario in which food is expensive. Nobody has the money to treat themselves, and nobody ever will. All money they get will go towards the very bare necessities such as good cloths and basic food
A district of all black people who've never actually won decide that this particular year they should rebel, solely because the stupid black girl died: They have won before, who said they haven't? And they rebelled because Katniss made Rue's death into a funereal, The Capitol doesn't want their people to feel sad for the dead tributes and Katniss did it in a rebellious way since The Capitol didn't want her to do that. (They've had several people die before, but now that Katniss is magically the first person to show compassion towards another candidate (which is also bs), it made the whole difference.) Well when you have a funereal it's for someone who you loved and it's suppose to be really sad and who knows maybe Rue was very well-known in D11.
This is a "what if" scenario as well as the definition of a plot hole. It isn't explained.
The bad guys are bad guys solely for the fact that they're smart enough to train potential picks and win every year: They aren't bad guys, Katniss is just jealous and thinks that they will win the Game, Katniss knows they were innocent children but hey, it's kill or be killed! Also the "bad guys" only know how to fight because in their district, they could train them too, The Capitol and District 1 & 2 had a closer relationship. (No, these guys were pretty much demonized the entire time. They viewed them like horrible people who should die, especially Cato. It wasn't until the second one where the other contestants weren't viewed as evil.) But Katniss hated them because they wanted to kill her but later in the games, she realizes that they are innocent, the capitol made them do this, it wasn't their fault. Trust me, if innocent people were forced to kill me, I would hate them.
And yet, they're still considered evil
The higher ups ##### out at the last second when Peeta and Katniss decide to threaten suicide, even though they had a multitude of ways to make sure on out lasts the other: That's why the higher-up died? Also what would you do if you were the super bowel and no one won? People would get furious that nobody won. (But the people didn't like the games to begin with. Why would they be upset from the result of a game they think is evil and cruel in the first place?) The people did like the games, well the people in The Capitol.
You're dancing around the point again. Those in charge of the game have numerous ways of assuring that one person will outlive the other. Sending out dogs, creating fire, letting the boarders close in, etc. Hell, they could even just wait and see who drops first after they both eat the berries. It makes no sense.
"Hit the lever!" |
|
AbsxlveJoin Date: 2012-06-21
Post Count: 8259 |
Oh hi Hulk long time no see and read the book it brings entertainment to our lives |
|
jason2926Join Date: 2009-08-30
Post Count: 12473 |
So much negativity in this thread |
|
|
|
James Dashner's books has a lot more plot holes than THG!! And why should I explain to you all this stuff, Im just wasting my time!! |
|
|
Really? How about in the maze runner, is there any plotholes |
|
|
"James Dashner's books has a lot more plot holes than THG!! And why should I explain to you all this stuff, Im just wasting my time!!"
We're not talking about James Dashner
We're talking about the hunger games
James Dashner is irreverent
You have no further arguments so you're attempting to change the topic and dance around my points
Don't claim something or make a statement if you're not prepared to back it up
"Hit the lever!" |
|
|
@Above um i wish you guys were because I get the point with the HG ._. |
|
ducky980Join Date: 2012-09-01
Post Count: 9083 |
Everything in scorch trials is pretty absurd. SPOILER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! My favorite is how at the end of the movie, the bad guys were overpowered by a few people. These bad guys had tons of high tech weapons and didn't use any of them on the protagonists. All of them just stopped shooting at the only few who were fighting against them. All they had to do was kill about 3 people and then move on with what they were doing. But all of them became useless, couldn't fire a single weapon. |
|
|
I can back it up but I would rather not waste my time and I was trying to go back to topic... |
|
|
Then back it up or admit defeat
"Hit the lever!" |
|
|
that's not how the world works sweetheart... |
|
ducky980Join Date: 2012-09-01
Post Count: 9083 |
I never said I didn't like it, it just has plot holes. |
|