PostPwnerJoin Date: 2011-07-14
Post Count: 81 |
Anyone can read this, and it's not long at all to be given a TL;DR.
---
The Suggestions and Ideas forum has lost its touch, and it's meaning. Instead of congratulating ideas that will IMPROVE* the experience of Roblox, we are usually just pointing out the flaws in bad ideas.
If that's the case, why do we need S&I? Why not argue over it in RT, or OT?
I am not generalizing that everyone posts bad ideas, I'm saying that Roblox is beginning to reach full potential, therefore the only ideas we have are for our own needs, not Roblox's. Ideas like that include more benefits for non-BC members, or a way to earn more tickets/robux.
There are still some good ideas many acknowledge, which I think should go to uservoice. Besides that, S&I is a place for conversation, spam, and useless ideas, so it'd be a good idea to remove the forum itself.
Uservoice is much more sophisticated for placing ideas, it's where you can see the status of it, if it's going to be used or not. Only top voted ideas will be displayed on the front pages, which will decrease the amount of spam you see. Besides, it's rare that an administrator views ideas on the S&I forum.
All I'm asking is that the S&I Forum should be deleted.
Please comment, or tell me why you disagree.
Thanks! :)
---
* When I say improve, I don't mean add extra features. Ideas such as new hats or gears aren't that much improving.
|
|
226611Join Date: 2012-01-23
Post Count: 4079 |
you are posting on what you want deleted?
lame.
and you, my friend, have -1337% support.
OM NOM NOM A NUBCAKE ABOVE EAT HIM! |
|
PostPwnerJoin Date: 2011-07-14
Post Count: 81 |
It's to get attention, not to say I support S&I all the way still. |
|
226611Join Date: 2012-01-23
Post Count: 4079 |
OM NOM NOM TASTEH NUBCAKE! |
|
PostPwnerJoin Date: 2011-07-14
Post Count: 81 |
Besides, this idea is aimed towards people who post on S&I, so if I didn't post this thread on this forum, what would be the point? |
|
|
No support..
S&I may not have admins approve of some ideas..
users can still suggest ideas.
what a silly idea.
|
|
226611Join Date: 2012-01-23
Post Count: 4079 |
OM NOM NOM oh thats all the nubcake i have. |
|
02AlienJoin Date: 2010-05-28
Post Count: 1869 |
I jus think forums should be moderated, and spam, and stupid ideas removed right away. There, problem solved. |
|
PostPwnerJoin Date: 2011-07-14
Post Count: 81 |
Bouncin, you must have skimmed through this without reading all of it.
Users can still suggest ideas on uservoice. |
|
226611Join Date: 2012-01-23
Post Count: 4079 |
OM NOM NOM YAY MORE NUBCAKE! |
|
PostPwnerJoin Date: 2011-07-14
Post Count: 81 |
Alien, if you could also understand this, there's too much to be moderated and filtered.
That's why I suggest S&I to be deleted. |
|
|
I dissaprove. S&I has its own little community.
Still, it might as well just be a hyperlink to Uservoice... |
|
226611Join Date: 2012-01-23
Post Count: 4079 |
YAY EVEN MORE NUBCAKE!
OM NOM NOM NOM NOM NOM NOM! |
|
PostPwnerJoin Date: 2011-07-14
Post Count: 81 |
@atomic
Exactly. And all we do is point out the flaws in bad ideas, which isn't helping Roblox, like the description of S&I says. |
|
|
S&I does not need to be removed, it needs to be updated with a support system and several other minor touches. We are criticising ideas because that is what people generally tend to do: point out the bad rather than the good. |
|
|
Roblox has so many flaws, this forum may as well be changed to "Roblox Flaw Discussion".
There are MILLIONS of things that could make this site better, but the admins do nothing.
~Axel |
|
PostPwnerJoin Date: 2011-07-14
Post Count: 81 |
Criticizing is still good, but S&I is to help improve Roblox. We can't always point out bad ideas. |
|
226611Join Date: 2012-01-23
Post Count: 4079 |
YUMMEH NUBCAKE!
OM NOM NOM! |
|
PostPwnerJoin Date: 2011-07-14
Post Count: 81 |
@axel
My point. S&I isn't really helping Roblox much, so why not delete it and just use uservoice instead? |
|
226611Join Date: 2012-01-23
Post Count: 4079 |
I CANT EAT ALL THIS NUBCAKE!
ILL TRY!
OM NOM NOM NOM NOM NOM NOM NOM NOM NOM NOM NOM NOM NOM NOM! |
|
PostPwnerJoin Date: 2011-07-14
Post Count: 81 |
If you read this through, and think about it, you may come to supporting this. |
|
|
PostPwnerJoin Date: 2011-07-14
Post Count: 81 |
Bumble, if you read it all, I never said all ideas are bad.
I'm saying it's better to use uservoice than S&I. |
|
|
This is my whome! 3: If you destwoy it, kitty no happy and no pwace sweep at night! |
|
sly475Join Date: 2008-12-20
Post Count: 2795 |
Post, while this would provide a solution, it would hinder Roblox in the end.
My point; S&I could actually be profitable to Roblox if only they utilized it.
But they don't.
It's not that Admin's don't read S&I, it's that we don't know if they do. They don't make their presence obvious, therefore no one hear tries to actually come up with a good idea. The majority of us believe admins don't read this, when in truth they probably check it every once in a while.
When they check it, they should make sure people know they are on. Commenting on ideas, making their own ideas, responding to posts on their threads would help us know they were here and reading, making us work harder to generate ideas.
|
|