of     11   
chevron_rightchevron_rightchevron_right

drgn42
#67570756Sunday, May 06, 2012 1:40 AM GMT

So, yeah, ROBLOX does have contests, but you don't get anything from them besides a virtual hat, which may or may not be satisfying, and the 1st place place isn't even that cool. What ROBLOX should do, once a year (or maybe every few years if they don't want to do it too often) is have an admin judged contest based on one topic, give the community 3 months to build the place to go with the contest, and then they start judging. Possibly a 1 dollar submit fee, so that the judges could get payed, I'm not sure though. There will be 2 qualifying rounds, and then 6 rounds to find the winner. The first qualifying round will be about if there's something in the place or not. If there isn't anything in it, and it's just an empty baseplate, or a starting place, they delete it from the competition. Maybe there would be an auto delete machine. I'm not really that sure. Maybe if the game doesn't have more than 40 items in it (bricks, scripts, guis, etc.) it would delete, or if it has one of the starter places that has more than 40 bricks. That would just make it a bit easier for the judges. The second qualifying round will still be easy, although it will eliminate tons of games. The judges will go through the places, checking the thumbnail to see if it looks like it has anything to do with the topic, and if it doesn't it would just be deleted. Finally, after the 2 qualifying rounds, the real rounds begin. The judges would look at the thumbnails, and set a standard for the places,and if the thumbnail did not meet the standards, it would be deleted. the second and third real rounds would follow the same way. By the fourth real round, it should be lowered down to about 200-700 places. The judges would then actually play the places, and see if they were any good, and if they are all good, they would see which ones were the best. They would have to delete places until they lowered it down from 50-150 places. On the fifth round, the judges have 50-150 places, and they write down compliments and things that would make it better and somehow notify the player that made it. They would lower it down to 10 places, and then move on to the next round. On the sixth and final round, they would make a video review for the top 10 places, showing on each one more critisism, and telling what made the place better from the others, and possibly a little trailer for the video. They would decide the top 3, give them a badge or whatever, possibly free month BC (not neccisary, I just thought it'd be a nice bonus), and on the games page, put a 'Contest of The Year (or how many ever years) Winners' box, and put the top 3 places on that for the rest of ROBLOX to see every single time they get on the games page until the next contest begins. The advantage to this is, instead of getting just a hat, you would get pretty much unlimited bragging rights, free advertisement, and... wait for it... a BADGE! I dunno, if ROBLOX wants to make a hat for them aswell, go ahead. This would make ROBLOX building have a point. To win. Rules ______________________________________________ I may not list some of the rules that ROBLOX would put in, just because I'm not perfect, and I may not even think about some. 1) Must follow rules of ROBLOX 2) Must follow the subject 3) Must be made by YOU 4) You must accept that you will be critisized if you make it far enough into the contest 5) The place must be active 6) If the place is in the top 3, you will have to keep it on your active places until ROBLOX does a new contest 7) Must follow any other rules ROBLOX would put on this list that I have forgotten.
Dude5683
#67573806Sunday, May 06, 2012 2:20 AM GMT

Agreed since everytime I look at the contests, it's free modeled look a likes that people vote for just because it "promises" a +5 vote. This is really needed, and heck I'm sure that people can do it since they have nothing better to do. 99% support.
drgn42
#67580290Sunday, May 06, 2012 4:01 AM GMT

Awesomeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
Paramore2
#67582698Sunday, May 06, 2012 4:42 AM GMT

...This is actually a great idea. You really thought this through and I've never seen it posted before. You have my full support! You should post this on User Voice!
starman444
#67583928Sunday, May 06, 2012 5:08 AM GMT

agree, i think you should change round 6 of the real judging a bit. Say, post it on youtube, and let the people there cast their votes. the youtube judging should be 5 days long, and the place that the majority voted for should be represented by one admin.
drgn42
#67596405Sunday, May 06, 2012 1:30 PM GMT

Maybe we could have a vote if the last round is user voted or not... I dunno. Sorta ironic.
Virtualdarks
#67596466Sunday, May 06, 2012 1:32 PM GMT

I miss the days when real contests were out every few months. -Virtualdarks
drgn42
#67596579Sunday, May 06, 2012 1:35 PM GMT

Yeah, I wish I was there to see it...
irondragonwarrior
#67598984Sunday, May 06, 2012 2:29 PM GMT

Support.
TheNegitivitron
#67599861Sunday, May 06, 2012 2:46 PM GMT

Support.
mikeythebrick56
#67601809Sunday, May 06, 2012 3:18 PM GMT

Total Support. You seriously took every aspect of ROBLOX in to mind and made it absolutely fool-proof. You made it so that ROBLOX Users would get advantage and the staff wont go and say,"Oh, this is gonna ruin our business. Let's ingnore this user." I love it. This is like the Mona Lisa of ROBLOX.
Crazace
#67605406Sunday, May 06, 2012 4:14 PM GMT

Yes. 'Nuff said.
Zyphral
#67605675Sunday, May 06, 2012 4:18 PM GMT

It's was similar this in the past... Sure.
drgn42
#67615234Sunday, May 06, 2012 6:34 PM GMT

Thanks for the supports. Hah, mikey it's sorta funny, because I start with a basic idea, take 2 minutes to type that up, and think of what I would do to take advantage of it, and figure out how to not do that, turning the thread from a 1 paragraph thing to a whole page.
TimberWolffe
#67633523Sunday, May 06, 2012 10:36 PM GMT

Total support except for one rule: must be kept in active places the alternative is that the user gets an extra active place for the contest entry and it can stay there, then when there's a new contest they get a message telling them to either update the place to the new theme or to make it their default active place, that way they could still be making what they want :D anyway, just think about that idea ~Lorem Ipsum solor dit amet~
drgn42
#67634807Sunday, May 06, 2012 10:53 PM GMT

Yeah, I was debating whether I should say that your place is locked active, but you get 2 active places if you're NBC, and 1 extra if you're BC TBC or OBC.
drgn42
#67636637Sunday, May 06, 2012 11:15 PM GMT

bump
drgn42
#67639549Sunday, May 06, 2012 11:54 PM GMT

11 supports :)
Aleezybaby0
#67640294Monday, May 07, 2012 12:04 AM GMT

This wouldn't hurt. Support.
drgn42
#67643850Monday, May 07, 2012 12:51 AM GMT

12 now.
quicktyplosion
#67660414Monday, May 07, 2012 8:44 AM GMT

"Possibly a 1 dollar submit" Supporting everything but that.
Espithel
#67660476Monday, May 07, 2012 8:52 AM GMT

Points for detail. A lot of points for detail. But one thing bugs me: the time it'd take.
drgn42
#67665731Monday, May 07, 2012 1:15 PM GMT

So, post above frozen, thats there so that you can pay the judges... It's not like they're gonna do this for free. and frozen, the dollars from the thousands of places submitted would pay them.
ifavila
#67665764Monday, May 07, 2012 1:17 PM GMT

Very well planned out. Support.
drgn42
#67686736Monday, May 07, 2012 10:52 PM GMT

Thanks.

    of     11   
chevron_rightchevron_rightchevron_right