|
spacegangJoin Date: 2011-07-03
Post Count: 3863 |
support
to all who disagree, you better have an idea than "no it will make roblox broke" |
|
|
|
they made it 20 seconds so no one can copy real songs |
|
spacegangJoin Date: 2011-07-03
Post Count: 3863 |
then they should add moderation for long songs if they actually are real songs |
|
ExtulsJoin Date: 2009-01-02
Post Count: 5557 |
"then they should add moderation for long songs if they actually are real songs"
Yeah. Let's just monitor EVERY SINGLE COPYRIGHTED SONG that user tries to upload. THAT'S not a waste of time. |
|
spacegangJoin Date: 2011-07-03
Post Count: 3863 |
you can tell a song is copied by seeing it's length and hearing what type it is and what title they tried putting |
|
ExtulsJoin Date: 2009-01-02
Post Count: 5557 |
So ROBLOX knows every song in the world, I take it? |
|
spacegangJoin Date: 2011-07-03
Post Count: 3863 |
"and what title they tried putting"
please reread that post |
|
ExtulsJoin Date: 2009-01-02
Post Count: 5557 |
So ROBLOX knows every song in the world, I take it? (x2) |
|
spacegangJoin Date: 2011-07-03
Post Count: 3863 |
"and what title they tried putting"
please reread that post [2] |
|
spacegangJoin Date: 2011-07-03
Post Count: 3863 |
roblox moderates sound for a reason |
|
ExtulsJoin Date: 2009-01-02
Post Count: 5557 |
Okay, clearly, you don't understand.
If ROBLOX doesn't know every song in the world, then how would they be able to tell if a song is copyrighted just by the title?
PLUS: People have used song names that have been used before. What if a user makes a song, and it has the name of another song? Should ROBLOX just assume it's copyrighted and then decline it? |
|
|
ExtulsJoin Date: 2009-01-02
Post Count: 5557 |
But with artists releasing songs so fast, how does ROBLOX keep up with their filter?
This would just take time away from all the other projects they're working on, which isn't really worth it.
Also...
"If you know anything about sound files,"
Don't treat me like an idiot. |
|
spacegangJoin Date: 2011-07-03
Post Count: 3863 |
people are already releasing songs "too fast"
mods are here for a reason
mods moderate to get paid |
|
ExtulsJoin Date: 2009-01-02
Post Count: 5557 |
"people are already releasing songs "too fast"
mods are here for a reason
mods moderate to get paid"
How does this argue anything I said? |
|
|
|
ExtulsJoin Date: 2009-01-02
Post Count: 5557 |
"You are clearly ignorant."
No. YOU are.
"An adapting filter utilizing a database that is updated would zap all of these problems in not time, the problem isn't copyright material the problem is inaccessibility. That is the real issue with our current system."
YouTube filters copyrighted sounds. Now tell me this: With the sounds filtered, how do people still get around to uploading videos with copyrighted audio files? |
|
spacegangJoin Date: 2011-07-03
Post Count: 3863 |
take a look at these songs
http://www.roblox.com/Dubstep-Gun-Sound-Saints-Row-4-DESC-item?id=130768080
http://www.roblox.com/Minecraft-Music-item?id=130790287
http://www.roblox.com/YOU-ARE-A-PIRATE-item?id=130774314
all these songs are constantly being uploaded every day
they are infringing rights since they can be looped
why do you think roblox allows these songs through
the number of audio is increasing fast
theres already 85 pages
they mod it "fast" |
|
|
ExtulsJoin Date: 2009-01-02
Post Count: 5557 |
"If you have a REAL solution, how about you post it instead of saying "well dat doesnt work1!!" Well if it doesn't work, how about you contribute something and find a better solution then what I am suggesting."
Once again, don't treat me like an idiot. If you continue to, I will become rude with my responses, as you are being to me.
I would suggest better, but have you ever though that maybe nothing has crossed my mind? You seriously need to stop and think for a second.
I love music.
I love composing.
If I had an idea to get past these issues, I would have posted it by now. |
|
spacegangJoin Date: 2011-07-03
Post Count: 3863 |
you already are being rude with your responses, you are an ignorant i tell you |
|
|